Compostable Bin Bags vs Biodegradable: Which Should You Use in 2025?

Compostable bin bags and biodegradable bags are often confused, but they are not the same—compostable bags are designed to break down under specific composting conditions, leaving no harmful residue, while biodegradable bags may take longer to decompose and can leave behind microplastics. The differences between these two options start with their materials and end with how they impact the environment after disposal.

People searching for greener waste solutions must understand these distinctions to make informed choices. An incorrect choice can affect both waste processing and the environment’s health in the long term.

Those considering which type of bin bag to use may be surprised by how standards, decomposition times, and aftermath differ. These key details can help anyone aiming to reduce their environmental footprint.

Understanding Compostable and Biodegradable Bin Bags

Compostable and biodegradable bin bags are made from different materials and break down in unique ways. Selecting the right type depends on both environmental goals and local waste processing methods.

What Are the Key Differences?

Compostable bin bags are designed to break down fully into natural elements when processed in home or industrial composting facilities. Standard compostable bags undergo strict testing to ensure they degrade within a specific timeframe, usually leaving no toxic residue.

Biodegradable bin bags can decompose through natural processes, but the term is less regulated. These bags might break down over a much longer period and do not always fully return to non-toxic, organic matter. Not every biodegradable bag is compostable, but all compostable bags are technically biodegradable under composting conditions.

A helpful comparison:

Feature	Compostable	Biodegradable
Regulation	Strong standards	Few or unclear
Composting Option	Yes	Not always
Breakdown Speed	Measured in weeks/months	Can take years
End Product	Organic matter	May leave microplastics

Visual and Material Distinctions

Compostable bin bags are often labeled with official certifications, such as the EN 13432 or ASTM D6400 standards. Their packaging usually mentions “100% compostable” and may display logos from certification organizations.

Biodegradable bags can look similar but may have looser labeling and fewer certifications. Their texture and thickness sometimes resemble conventional plastic. Compostable bags often feel slightly softer or more paper-like, depending on the materials used.

Some compostable bags may appear translucent or have a green tint, while many biodegradable bags are clear or opaque. It is important to read the label to distinguish between compostable and biodegradable options, as appearances can be misleading.

Types of Materials Used

Compostable bin bags are typically made from plant-based materials, such as cornstarch, potato starch, or polylactic acid (PLA). These bio-based plastics are designed to break down in compost environments and do not leave harmful residues.

Biodegradable bin bags can be made from traditional plastics modified with additives to speed up degradation, or from blends of plant-based and synthetic materials. Biodegradable plastics may not fully degrade and can leave microplastics behind, depending on conditions and their exact composition.

Compostable materials are suitable for composting facilities, while biodegradable materials may not always meet the requirements for composting. Understanding the material composition helps ensure bin bags are disposed of in a way that matches their intended breakdown process.

How Do Compostable Bin Bags Work?

Compostable bin bags are designed to break down into non-toxic materials under the right composting conditions. Their effectiveness depends on the composting process used and how the bags are certified.

Composting Process and Mechanisms

Compostable bin bags are made from plant-based polymers, such as cornstarch or polylactic acid (PLA). During composting, these materials are broken down by microorganisms in an aerobic environment. 

Heat, moisture, and oxygen are essential for the degradation process. In active compost piles, microbes digest the bags, converting them into water, carbon dioxide, and organic matter.

Unlike conventional plastics, compostable bags do not fragment into microplastics. Instead, they should fully disintegrate, leaving no visible residue or harmful chemicals in the resulting compost.

Home vs. Industrial Composting

Home composting involves smaller-scale bins or piles, with moderate temperatures and varied microorganisms. Most home composting environments do not reach the heat levels required to break down many compostable products, especially thicker or industrially certified bags.

Industrial composting facilities maintain higher temperatures—around 55–60°C—and provide optimized airflow and moisture. These controlled environments can process a wider range of compostable packaging and materials, ensuring they degrade within specific timeframes.

Many compostable bin bags labeled as “industrial compostable” will not fully break down in a backyard compost bin. It’s important to check packaging for a “home compostable” certification if home composting is the intended use.

Compostable Certifications and Standards

Compostable bin bags must meet specific standards to ensure they break down safely and completely. In North America, the ASTM D6400 standard is commonly used for industrial compostability, while AS 5810 and OK Compost Home apply to home composting.

Biodegradable Products Institute (BPI) certification verifies products meet ASTM standards. Look for official labels, such as:

Certification Label	Suitable For	Meaning
BPI Compostable	Industrial Composting	Meets ASTM D6400; degrades at facility
OK Compost Home	Home Composting	Suitable for lower-temp, home compost

Proper certification helps buyers avoid “greenwashed” products that may not fully break down or that leave contaminants behind. Always review certification details before choosing compostable bags.

How Do Biodegradable Bin Bags Work?

Biodegradable bin bags break down through natural processes involving microorganisms, unlike traditional plastics that persist for years. Not all biodegradable bags are created equal, and their breakdown varies depending on composition and environmental conditions.

What is biodegradation?

Biodegradation is the process where materials are broken down by living organisms, mainly bacteria and fungi, into water, carbon dioxide, and biomass. Biodegradable plastics are designed to start this breakdown when exposed to certain environments, typically involving moisture, oxygen, and microorganisms.

Standard plastic bags resist these natural processes. Biodegradable bin bags are manufactured to lose structural integrity over time. However, the end products of biodegradation may still include small plastic fragments, which could persist as microplastics if the process is incomplete.

The effectiveness and speed of biodegradation depend on factors like temperature, humidity, and presence of suitable microbes.

Oxo-Degradable and Degradable Bags

Oxo-degradable bags are conventional plastics mixed with additives that promote fragmentation when exposed to heat and oxygen. These bags break into smaller pieces more quickly compared to traditional plastics but may not fully decompose into harmless substances. Instead, they often leave behind microplastics, which can accumulate in the environment.

Other degradable bags may rely on chemical additives or simply mechanical degradation, rather than true biodegradation via microbes. There is ongoing debate and regulation surrounding these bags, as they do not always meet the criteria for full environmental safety.

When labeled “biodegradable,” a product may still require specific industrial processes or conditions to break down effectively, and not all are suitable for home composting.

Decomposition Timelines and Conditions

Decomposition time for biodegradable bags varies widely. Under optimal conditions—such as high heat, moisture, and active microbial communities in industrial composting facilities—these bags can break down in a few months.

In home compost bins or landfills, where conditions are less controlled, biodegradation may take several years or even stall entirely. Factors like lack of oxygen, insufficient moisture, and low temperatures can significantly slow the process.

Table: Estimated Biodegradation Times

Environment	Typical Timeline
Industrial Compost Facility	3-6 months
Home Compost	1-2 years (variable)
Landfill	Several years or longer

Full breakdown and avoidance of microplastics depend on both the design of the bag and the environment in which it is discarded. Proper disposal is key to realizing the intended benefits of biodegradable packaging.

What Are the Environmental and Practical Impacts?

Compostable and biodegradable bin bags each bring different outcomes for the environment, waste processing, and recycling infrastructure. Their benefits and drawbacks depend on how they break down and the systems available to handle them.

Environmental Impact and Microplastic Concerns

Compostable bin bags are designed to break down into natural materials under specific composting conditions, typically producing water, carbon dioxide, and biomass. They do not create toxic residues when processed correctly.

Biodegradable bags, on the other hand, only need to degrade from the action of microorganisms, but they lack standardized testing for complete breakdown. Biodegradable plastics can leave behind microplastics if they do not fully decompose, which can persist in soil and water. Microplastics are a concern for food chains and water quality.

In terms of greenhouse gas emissions, compostable bags may contribute less if composted properly, since aerobic composting generates less methane compared to decomposition in landfills.

Disposal and Waste Management

Compostable bin bags must be disposed of in industrial composting facilities or home compost systems that reach the required temperature and conditions. If placed in normal landfill, compostable bags may not break down fully and can behave like conventional plastic.

Biodegradable bags do not require specific composting environments but often still need long exposure to microorganisms, light, or heat, conditions that are rarely met in landfills. This incomplete decomposition can result in plastic fragments lingering in the environment.

In terms of waste management, the correct disposal route is critical:

• Compostable bags: Industrial compost or suitable home compost
• Biodegradable bags: Typically meant for landfill or incineration, but effectiveness depends on location

Let’s Talk Recycling

Neither compostable nor biodegradable bags should be placed in standard plastic recycling streams. Mixing these with recyclable plastics can contaminate recycling batches, resulting in entire loads being sent to landfill or incineration.

Facilities often lack the ability to distinguish between compostable, biodegradable, and conventional plastics, making it important for consumers to consult local guidance.

Recycling systems are not designed to process these alternative materials. Proper separation and clear labeling help minimize contamination and support effective waste streams. Mismanagement at this stage can undermine the environmental advantages these bags are meant to offer.

How Do I Choose the Right Bag for Sustainability?

Selecting the right bag for eco-friendly waste management depends on its intended use, underlying materials, and recognized certifications. Understanding product suitability, types of packaging, and trustworthy labels is essential for consumers seeking minimum environmental impact.

Applications and Suitability

Compostable bin bags are designed to break down effectively in industrial or home composting environments, usually within a specific time frame. They work best for collecting food scraps or organic waste that is destined for compost facilities.

Biodegradable bags degrade through natural processes but may leave microplastics behind unless they meet strict standards. They are not always suitable for home composting and often require particular conditions to break down fully.

For households prioritizing waste diversion, compostable bags offer a better option when local composting services are available. Biodegradable bags may be more appropriate where composting isn’t accessible, but users should check for product details to avoid greenwashing.

Let’s Compare Eco-Friendly Packaging Options:

Eco-friendly packaging includes compostable, biodegradable, and recyclable products. Compostable packaging is made from renewable materials, like cornstarch or plant fibers, designed to become nutrient-rich compost.

Biodegradable packaging can be either plant-based or derived from fossil fuels and might not fully decompose in typical landfill conditions. Recyclable packaging—such as certain plastics and papers—offers another path for reducing waste, provided there are systems in place for collection and processing.

The most sustainable packaging usually lists its composition and intended disposal method, ensuring compatibility with local waste management practices. Choosing BPI-certified compostable products adds another layer of confidence.

Labels, Certifications, and Regulations

Reliable labels and certifications help consumers distinguish genuinely sustainable options. The Biodegradable Products Institute (BPI) certifies compostable bags and verifies that they meet ASTM standards for compostability.

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) sets guidelines on environmental marketing claims to prevent misleading labels around terms like “compostable” or “biodegradable.” Honest, third-party certifications are critical; improper use of these terms can contribute to consumer confusion and undermine trust.

Look for clear labeling such as “BPI Certified Compostable,” which signals that the product has passed rigorous independent testing. Always review product packaging for official seals and compliance with regulations to ensure the bag aligns with true sustainability standards.

---